Supreme Court leaves Federal Circuit rule on patent equivalents intact
The denial of certiorari in Genuine Enabling Technology v. Sony leaves strict proof rules in place for means-plus-function claims
By Letizia Giugliano
2 min readWritten with AI support · Reviewed and approved by: Letizia Giugliano

The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear an appeal challenging how federal courts evaluate equivalents under patent law. The decision in Genuine Enabling Technology LLC v. Sony Group Corp. leaves in place a strict Federal Circuit requirement that forces patent owners to explain why separate technical components are equivalent.
A dispute over console controllers
The legal battle began when Genuine Enabling Technology LLC accused Sony Group Corp. of infringing U.S. Patent No. 6,219,730. The patent, which traces its priority back to a patent application filed in 1998, covers an apparatus designed to synchronize multiple user input streams into a single combined data stream, as reported by IPWatchdog. Genuine Enabling Technology targeted Sony PlayStation consoles and controllers, which transmit button presses and motion data from an accelerometer over a single Bluetooth connection.
At the trial level, the District of Delaware granted summary judgment of non-infringement to Sony under the doctrine of equivalents. The court found that the patent owner failed to account for several components inside logic block 34, a framing element in the patent specification. Genuine Enabling Technology appealed, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the judgment in February 2026.
The burden of the why requirement
Under 35 U.S.C. § 112(f), an inventor may express an element in a claim as a means or step for performing a specified function. Such claims cover the corresponding structure described in the specification and its equivalents. To prove infringement under the doctrine of equivalents, courts apply the classic function-way-result test established in the 1950 case Graver Tank & Manufacturing v. Linde Air Products.
Over several decades, the Federal Circuit added an explicit evidentiary hurdle known as the why requirement. Stemming from cases such as Lear Sigler v. Sealy Mattress Co. of Michigan and Malta v. Schulmerich Carillons, this standard requires patentees to explain specifically why an accused component operates in substantially the same way as the claimed structure, as detailed by IPWatchdog. In logic circuit design, where engineers routinely swap or rearrange interchangeable components, meeting this legal threshold as a matter of law can prove difficult.
What the denial means for intellectual property litigation
In its petition for certiorari filed in September, Genuine Enabling Technology argued that the appellate court misapplied established precedent. The company cited the 1999 decision Odetics v. Storage Technology Corp., which held that individual components of an overall structure corresponding to a claimed function are not individual claim limitations. Genuine Enabling Technology asserted that the Federal Circuit had improperly extended the why requirement into Section 112(f) through its 2021 ruling in Traxcell Technologies v. Sprint Communications.
Several appellate judges, including Circuit Judges Pauline Newman, Jimmie Reyna and Alan Lourie, have dissented from the court's strict application of the rule in earlier proceedings, according to IPWatchdog. The full appellate bench declined to revisit the standard, and the Supreme Court denial means the heightened standard of proof remains binding law for intellectual property litigators nationwide.
An article by the newsroom of The Patent ®, written with the support of artificial intelligence from sources chosen by the newsroom. Review, corrections and approval for publication: Letizia Giugliano. Publisher responsible: WitUp Ltd.



